Homeschool Myth: Manipulatives
Now there will be times when, depending on the kid, you might need a real mainpulative. Take for example those lovely unit blocks in my picture. All kids may not need those but the NerdBug's math progress came to a screeching halt when we got to borrowing and carrying so we went and got a little help. Something you need to keep in mind is the local teacher store isn't your only option, and sometime that is a costly option. I went into our local teacher store (GW Supply) and found some unit blocks but not all that I wanted. They had the tens and the ones but not the hundreds and they were about $9 a bag. So I went on line and found these interlocking ones at a fraction of the price and they lock together (the ones at GW didn't). All I did was go to the website on the bag. After shipping and handling I still paid less (less than $18 for all 3 sets plus a couple of clearance items;). So remember to look around. The Internet is your oyster!
One last thing, if you are going to invest in something try to make it do double duty. It can teach basic addition and subtraction, carrying, borrowing and fractions.
This is the first manipulative I needed to buy so that myth is officially debunked!
Labels: education, frugal homeschooling, Homeschoooling
4 Comments:
You have to figure that people schooled JUST FINE before The Great Buy A Lot Of Stuff Movement. I doubt the one-room school houses were loaded with plastic totes filled with manipulatives.
It's like the whole "my kids need a lot of toys" concept. Bunk!
By
Unknown, at 11:45 PM
I use a math curriculum that does require a whole lot of manipulatives (Right Start). But although there was a fairly high initial start-up cost, over the long run it's not going to be so much. All I'm going to need for the rest of elementary math for my family are the 2 teacher's manuals I haven't yet gotten plus the student workbooks. And when I'm done, I should be able to recoup at least a portion of what I spent.
By
Crimson Wife, at 9:41 AM
239
there are 239 blocks
definitely, 239.
By
Vessel, at 5:03 PM
Interestingly enough, there's a moderate amount of research that is showing that using manipulatives to teach a concept may actual decrease conceptual retention!
To be honest, it makes sense to me - it's easy enough to get distracted by the physical object enough so that the concept isn't retained, but I assumed that it was only me.
Anyway, they're no doubt useful on occasion, but don't feel that they're a requirement for successful teaching.
By
Anonymous, at 2:48 AM
Post a Comment
<< Home